Power in a three-phase system

Power in a three-phase system – instantaneous values pL1(t), pL2(t), pL3(t) and total power p(t)

Phasors of RMS values URMS, IRMS. Voltages and currents are drawn to different scales.
CALCULATION RESULTS
MODE
COMMON (L1, L2, L3)
φ > 0 current lags (inductive load), φ < 0 capacitive load
PHASE L1 (0°)
PHASE L2 (−120°)
PHASE L3 (+120°)
DISPLAY
Powers (lower plot)
Upper plot

Instantaneous power in a three-phase system

This model follows on from the page Electric power, which describes power in a single-phase circuit, and uses the same notation. A three-phase system consists of phases L1, L2 and L3, whose voltages are shifted by 120° relative to each other. Each phase behaves as a separate single-phase circuit with its own instantaneous power \(p_{L1}(t)\), \(p_{L2}(t)\) and \(p_{L3}(t)\). The load as a whole draws their sum \(p(t)\). The model assumes a star connection with the neutral conductor brought out, so \(u_{Lk}\) are the phase voltages with respect to the star point N.

Phase voltages and currents

\[ u_{L1}(t) = U_{\text{max},1}\sin(\omega t), \qquad u_{L2}(t) = U_{\text{max},2}\sin(\omega t - 120^\circ), \qquad u_{L3}(t) = U_{\text{max},3}\sin(\omega t + 120^\circ) \]
\[ i_{Lk}(t) = I_{\text{max},k}\sin(\omega t + \theta_k - \varphi_k), \qquad \theta_1 = 0^\circ,\; \theta_2 = -120^\circ,\; \theta_3 = +120^\circ \]

The angle \(\varphi_k\) is the phase shift between the voltage and the current of phase \(k\), just like the angle \(\varphi\) in a single-phase circuit. For a positive angle the current lags the voltage, the load is inductive and \(Q_k > 0\). For a negative angle the current leads the voltage and the load is capacitive. In the balanced system mode \(U_{\text{MAX}}\), \(I_{\text{MAX}}\) and \(\varphi\) are set for all three phases at once, in the individual phases mode each phase has its own values.

Power of one phase

The instantaneous power of a phase is the product of its voltage and current

\[ p_{Lk}(t) = u_{Lk}(t) \cdot i_{Lk}(t) = U_{\text{max},k} I_{\text{max},k} \sin(\omega t + \theta_k) \sin(\omega t + \theta_k - \varphi_k) \]

Substituting the RMS values \(U_{\text{RMS},k} = U_{\text{max},k}/\sqrt{2}\), \(I_{\text{RMS},k} = I_{\text{max},k}/\sqrt{2}\) and rearranging with the identity \(\sin\alpha \cdot \sin\beta = \frac{1}{2}\left[\cos(\alpha-\beta) - \cos(\alpha+\beta)\right]\) gives

\[ p_{Lk}(t) = U_{\text{RMS},k} I_{\text{RMS},k} \big[\cos\varphi_k - \cos(2\omega t + 2\theta_k - \varphi_k)\big] \]

This is the same expression as in a single-phase circuit, only shifted by the phase angle \(\theta_k\). The phase power oscillates at twice the frequency (100 Hz in a 50 Hz network) around the mean value \(P_k\) and for \(\varphi_k \neq 0\) it is negative for at least part of the period. The active, reactive and apparent power of a phase are

\[ P_k = U_{\text{RMS},k} I_{\text{RMS},k} \cos\varphi_k, \qquad Q_k = U_{\text{RMS},k} I_{\text{RMS},k} \sin\varphi_k, \qquad S_k = U_{\text{RMS},k} I_{\text{RMS},k} \]

and for the whole system \(P = P_1 + P_2 + P_3\) and \(Q = Q_1 + Q_2 + Q_3\).

Total instantaneous power with a balanced load

\[ p(t) = p_{L1}(t) + p_{L2}(t) + p_{L3}(t) = \sum_{k=1}^{3} P_k \; - \; \sum_{k=1}^{3} S_k \cos(2\omega t + 2\theta_k - \varphi_k) \]

If all three phases are identical (\(U_{\text{RMS},k} = U_{\text{RMS}}\), \(I_{\text{RMS},k} = I_{\text{RMS}}\), \(\varphi_k = \varphi\)), the oscillating terms have the same amplitude \(U_{\text{RMS}} I_{\text{RMS}}\) and their phases are \(-\varphi\), \(-\varphi - 240^\circ\) and \(-\varphi + 240^\circ\). A shift of \(\pm 240^\circ\) is the same as a shift of \(\mp 120^\circ\), so these are three cosine waves shifted by 120° relative to each other. Their sum is zero at every instant

\[ \cos x + \cos(x - 120^\circ) + \cos(x + 120^\circ) = 0 \]

and the total power reduces to

\[ p(t) = 3\,U_{\text{RMS}} I_{\text{RMS}} \cos\varphi = P = \text{const.} \]

The powers of the individual phases pulsate and at certain instants are even negative, but their sum is constant. This is one of the main advantages of the three-phase system. A balanced three-phase motor or generator has a constant torque on its shaft, whereas a single-phase load draws from the network a power that pulsates at 100 Hz.

The case \(\varphi = 90^\circ\) is instructive. The power of each phase is \(p_{Lk}(t) = -U_{\text{RMS}} I_{\text{RMS}} \sin(2\omega t + 2\theta_k)\), just as in a single-phase circuit, and its mean value is zero. The total instantaneous power is zero at every instant, even though the reactive power \(Q = 3\,U_{\text{RMS}} I_{\text{RMS}}\) is not zero. The energy oscillations in the individual phases cancel each other out. The reactive power of a three-phase system therefore cannot be explained simply as energy oscillating between the source and the load, since it does not appear in the total instantaneous power \(p(t)\) at all.

Unbalanced load

If the phases differ in current, phase shift or voltage, the oscillating terms do not cancel and the total power \(p(t)\) pulsates at frequency \(2f\) around the mean value \(P\). The pulsation amplitude \(\Delta p\) is most easily determined from the RMS phasors \(\bar{U}_k\) and \(\bar{I}_k\), whose magnitudes are \(U_{\text{RMS},k}\) and \(I_{\text{RMS},k}\). The instantaneous power of a phase is

\[ p_{Lk}(t) = \mathrm{Re}\left\{\bar{U}_k \bar{I}_k^{*}\right\} - \mathrm{Re}\left\{\bar{U}_k \bar{I}_k\, e^{\,j2\omega t}\right\} \]

The first term is the active power \(P_k\), the second is the oscillating component. Summing over the phases gives the pulsation amplitude of the total power

\[ \Delta p = \left|\sum_{k=1}^{3} \bar{U}_k \bar{I}_k\right| = 3\left|\bar{U}_0\bar{I}_0 + \bar{U}_1\bar{I}_2 + \bar{U}_2\bar{I}_1\right| \]

where the indices 0, 1 and 2 denote the zero, positive and negative sequence components. With balanced voltages (\(\bar{U}_0 = \bar{U}_2 = 0\)) we get \(\Delta p = 3\,|\bar{U}_1|\,|\bar{I}_2|\). The total power therefore pulsates exactly when the load current contains a negative sequence component. The pulsation is not related to reactive power, an unbalanced purely resistive load has \(Q = 0\), yet its power \(p(t)\) pulsates. With balanced voltages the zero sequence current does not contribute to the pulsation, but it appears as a current in the neutral conductor

\[ i_N(t) = i_{L1}(t) + i_{L2}(t) + i_{L3}(t), \qquad \bar{I}_N = 3\,\bar{I}_0 \]

If the phases have different power factors, the arithmetic sum of the apparent powers \(S_1 + S_2 + S_3\) is greater than \(\sqrt{P^2 + Q^2}\). The apparent power of an unbalanced system is not uniquely defined, the standard IEEE Std 1459 deals with this question in more detail.

Using the model

  • In Balanced system mode the sliders in the COMMON section change \(U_{\text{MAX}}\), \(I_{\text{MAX}}\) and \(\varphi\) for all three phases at once.
  • In Individual phases mode each phase has its own sliders. After switching, the current common values are taken over, so it is enough to change one phase and watch how the constant waveform of \(p(t)\) is disturbed.
  • The switches in the DISPLAY section turn on the waveforms \(p_{L1}(t)\), \(p_{L2}(t)\), \(p_{L3}(t)\), the total power \(p(t)\), the mean values \(P_k\) and \(P\) and the shading of negative areas. The upper plot can show the voltages, the currents and the neutral conductor current.
  • The example buttons set up typical cases. With load on phase L1 only, the total power is the same as in a single-phase circuit.
  • The y-axis range is determined only from \(U_{\text{MAX}}\) and \(I_{\text{MAX}}\) as the largest value the waveform can reach for any angle \(\varphi\). The axis therefore does not change when the phase shift is changed, and the change in power can be compared directly. The power of a phase never exceeds \(U_{\text{max}} I_{\text{max}}\), the total power of a balanced system never exceeds \(1.5\,U_{\text{max}} I_{\text{max}}\).
  • The phasor diagram shows the RMS values \(U_{\text{RMS}}\) and \(I_{\text{RMS}}\). The arrow lengths are scaled to the largest voltage and the largest current, so voltages and currents are drawn to different scales.